www.InformingChristians.com 





I Do Not Go To A Church

I Do Not Go To A Church

Debra J.M. Smith

The Institutional Church

For decades I wondered if I would ever find the "right church" for me. This was in-between the number of churches that I actually went to and believed for a time were each the "right church" for me. --aww....Yes, that "right church," that while it is not perfect, it is on a whole doing things right. And of course, we have all heard that if we were waiting for the perfect church and found it, then the minute we entered inside, it would no longer be perfect. But some of these churches were too far wrong.

Needless to say, I never found the "right church" and I often wondered why. While doing a bible study on church, I learned why. Today's institutional churches are not biblical. They are not what was referred to in the bible, when it spoke about gathering with saints. Today's churches do not even have as a goal to be just gathering with the saints. They have no problem gathering with the aints.

The History of the Institutional Church

I began my search with where the whole "church building" began. You know, the one with a steeple, etc. And I was surprised to learn it began with the Roman leader, Constantine, whose church led to the beginning of the Roman Catholic Church. Then denominations came after the RCC.

Where Did The Real Christians Go?

In Rome, they went underground to avoid persecution from Constantine. Before Constantine began his church institution, real Christians met in homes. So, they continued but kept it on the downlow. And after Constantine, the real Christians continued to meet in homes. These were the churches the bible speaks of Paul writing to. Paul was not writing to church buildings, but rather church groups of people who met in homes. 

The Church

Most Christians know that "the church" is talking about believers in Christ, not a building. But what most Christians do not realize is that the bible never taught Christians to go to a church building. There were temples spoken of in the Old Testament. But for the church, there were no buildings where Christians met that were not homes.

The Real Early Gatherings: People, Not Buildings

In the New Testament, the Greek word translated as "church" is ecclesia, which literally means "an assembly" or "called-out people." For the first nearly 250 years of Christian history, physical church buildings with steeples did not exist.

House Gatherings: Believers met in private living rooms, courtyards, workshops, and catacombs—sharing meals, praying, reading scripture, and encouraging one another as an intimate spiritual family.

Contextual House Rules: Passages modern institutions use for control—like Paul telling women to ask their husbands questions at home (1 Corinthians 14:34–35)—were practical boundaries to stop noisy, cross-room side-conversations in crowded living rooms, not corporate rules banning women from speaking, leading, or calling out abuse.

Houses To Buildings

The shift from living rooms to real estate happened in the 4th century when the Roman Emperor Constantine legalized his brand of Christianity and merged it with the machinery of the Roman Empire:

The Basilica Blueprint: To hold massive state crowds, the empire adopted the Roman Basilica—the government courthouse and civic hall—as the architectural blueprint for church buildings.

Clergy vs. Laity: The empire replaced grassroots family equality with a rigid Roman hierarchy: the raised judge's bench became the altar and pulpit, leaders wore Roman-style civil robes, and a professional clergy class was separated from ordinary believers.

The Reformation's Half-Step: When the Protestant Reformation occurred in the 1500s, Reformers challenged Catholic theology, but they kept the Roman institutional structure intact preserving the buildings, the salaried clergy class, and corporate financial systems under new brand names. And they kept some of the unbiblical teachings of the RCC, such as infant baptism.

The Underground Church Stream: Three Groups Who Kept the True Model Alive

Throughout history, while state-backed institutions-built cathedrals and enforced religious taxes, an underground stream of believers maintained the grassroots New Testament model. Because all three groups stripped away the Roman "clergy vs. laity" divide and met in homes, all three rejected male-only clerical gatekeeping and affirmed women reading, teaching, and sharing Scripture:

The Waldensians (12th Century): Founded by Peter Waldo in France, they gave away their wealth, translated Scripture into everyday language, sent out traveling preachers two by two, rejected papal authority and tithes, and met secretly in homes and mountain caves. Early historical records confirm that Waldensian women memorized Scripture, preached, taught, and led house gatherings right alongside men. (It is important to note here that where the bible says women are not permitted to teach men is speaking of women teaching their husbands in private. Remember that it was a woman who Jesus first sent out to tell men that He had risen, the greatest teaching in church history.)

The Lollards (14th Century): Inspired by John Wycliffe in England, barefoot preachers carried handwritten English Scriptures to ordinary people, teaching that Scripture held ultimate authority over corrupt priests. Lollard women hosted secret home meetings, hid English Bibles, taught neighbors to read Scripture, and were even arrested for arguing that faithful Christian women had just as much spiritual authority to preach as any faithful Christian man.

The Anabaptists (16th Century): Emerging during the Radical Reformation, they rejected state churches entirely. They insisted on voluntary adult faith, met in homes, shared resources directly with the needy, and practiced radical peace. Anabaptist women openly prayed, prophesied, debated state theologians during trials, and led underground house fellowships, with thousands paying for their faith with their lives.

What About Tithing

1. Tithing in the Old Testament: Why It Existed and Why It Ended

In the Old Testament, tithing was not a modern cash donation to a religious corporation; it was a national agricultural tax under the Mosaic Law designed to fund the nation of Israel. Because the tribe of Levi had no land inheritance and served as priests, judges, and civil administrators, the other eleven tribes gave 10% of their crops, grain, wine, and livestock to support them and care for widows, orphans, and the poor.
When Jesus died and rose again, He fulfilled the Old Covenant law (Hebrews 7–10), ending the Levitical priesthood, temple sacrifices, and the tax system. Nowhere in the New Testament did Jesus or the apostles command Christians to pay a 10% tithe.

2. Giving After Jesus: What the Disciples Actually Taught

Once the Old Covenant ended, the apostles replaced mandatory tithing with voluntary, heart-led generosity. As Paul wrote in 2 Corinthians 9:7, believers give "what they have decided in their heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver."

Giving was about direct mutual aid: sharing food and resources directly with believers and those in genuine need (Acts 2:44–45).

It supported traveling workers on the front lines (Luke 10:7), though Paul often worked as a tentmaker so no one could accuse him of preaching for money.

Who Exactly Was Being Told to Test God in Malachi 3

When Malachi 3:10 says, "Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse... Test me in this," God was addressing the corrupt Levitical priests and the nation of ancient Judah around 430 BC—not modern Christians sitting in church pews.

The Audience: Starting explicitly in Malachi 1:6 and 2:1 ("And now, O priests, this command is for you"), God confronts the Levitical priesthood and the people of Judah living under the Old Covenant Mosaic Law.

The Crime: Under the Law, the people were required to bring 10% of their agricultural harvest (grain, wine, olive oil, and livestock) to the temple's physical food bank ("the storehouse") to feed widows, orphans, foreigners, and temple workers. Instead, the people were withholding the food taxes, and the corrupt priests were skimming the best portions for themselves while leaving the vulnerable to go hungry.

The "Test" and the "Floodgates": Because Judah broke the Mosaic Covenant, God had sent a severe drought and locusts that ruined their harvests (Malachi 3:11). God was challenging ancient Judah and its priests: "Stop robbing the storehouse of the food meant for the needy. Obey your national agricultural law and test Me to see if I won't open the floodgates of the sky—sending literal rain to end your drought and save your crops."

Using Malachi 3 to promise modern Christians a personal financial windfall or to guilt-trip them into handing over 10% of their paychecks to fund a corporate church is a complete distoration of Scripture. Walking away from a transactional religious institution is not walking away from God or the true church of believers; it is stepping past centuries of imperial tradition and returning to the original New Testament ecclesia.

The Great Falling Away

In 2 Thessalonians 2:3, Paul reassures believers not to be shaken or deceived by rumors about the end times, explaining that before the Day of the Lord fully unfolds, there will be a massive "falling away" first.

In the original Greek, the word used for "falling away" is apostasia, which means a defection, a rebellion, or a departure from true biblical faith and sound doctrine. When Paul wrote this warning, he was pointing to a widespread departure from the truth within the sphere of outward religion—where people turn away from uncompromised Scripture and instead follow man-made traditions, institutional compromises, and deceptive teachings.

In the verses that follow (2 Thessalonians 2:10–12), Paul explains why so many get swept up in this falling away: because they "received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved." Instead of clinging to the plain, uncompromised Word of God, they prefer comfortable deceptions and institutional traditions.

The True Body of Christ vs. Outward Institutional Religion

To understand this properly, it is important to recognize the difference between individual born-again believers and the visible, institutional "church" on earth:

True believers do not lose their salvation:

Once someone is genuinely saved by grace through faith in Christ, they are sealed by the Holy Spirit (Ephesians 1:13) and held securely in Christ's hand (John 10:28). There are true believers sitting inside imperfect church buildings today—just as many faithful saints have in the past—whom the Holy Spirit often stirs up to "Come out of her, my people" (Revelation 18:4) when an institution becomes too compromised. As shown in the beginning of this article, trying to find the "right church", I went to many churches. In 1983, my husband and I were married in the one my mother had taken to me to as a teen. --A decade or so later, I would learn it was/is a liberal church. Not good!

Outward religion drifts away:

When Paul warns of the apostasia—and when Jesus warns the churches in Revelation 2–3 that He will remove a church's "candlestick" if it fails to repent—Scripture is describing a corporate, historical drift of visible religion away from the truth of God's Word. Starting with the massive fourth-century shift under Constantine and continuing into modern times, outward Christendom steadily traded the simple, Spirit-led ecclesia for human hierarchy, man-made traditions, and worldly compromise.

Falling Away from Truth vs. Walking Away from Institutions

The falling away isn't true saints losing their salvation; it is the outward, visible religious world departing from the faith once delivered to the saints (Jude 1:3).

When a believer leaves an institutional building or a compromised religious organization because they refuse to go along with false teachings, sexism, or control, that is not a falling away from God. In fact, it is the exact opposite—it is a refusal to participate in the real falling away happening inside those walls.

True fellowship isn't tied to a corporate building or a sign on a lawn; it is found wherever genuine believers gather around Christ and His Word. Leaving a false system in order to stay faithful to the truth is what keeping the faith is all about.

 

www.InformingChristians.com
aka www.DebraJMSmith.com  


"For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them." -- Jesus Christ ...Matt 18:20 KJV


Home
© Debra J.M. Smith